we believe in

good food + good people.

Miss Molly's is a cozy cafe that offers fresh, healthy meals and scratch-made bakery served by people who care about the food we make and the people we feed.

Our cafe is committed to sustainability for our planet by composting almost all waste and for our community by working with local farmers and businesses to supply everything from veggies and grains to locally made soda, coffee and tea.

Shout out to some of our local partners!

Compost Crusader Yuppie Hill Poultry

Anodyne Coffee Roasting Company Hometown Sausage Kitchen

Rishi Tea Great River Organic Milling

WiscoPop! Blue Ribbon Organics

Springdale Farm Purple Door Ice Cream

Willoway Farm The Village Cheese Shop

Carr Valley Cheese Sassy Cow Creamery

Tapuat Kombucha Anderson Maple Syrup


9201 W. Center St.
Milwaukee, WI 53222

Monday- closed
Tuesday - Saturday 7a-3p
Sunday 7a-2p

Cafe: 414.249.5665

Catering + Events: 262.794.6192

Our Menu

As the season changes, so does our menu. Check back or give us a call for daily bakery updates.

Place your order online for fast and easy pick up. Click on the "Order Online" tab above. 



Owner/Pastry Chef

It’s hard to say when Molly decided to pursue pastries as a profession but she has always had a sweet tooth. As a Wauwatosa native, she spent many summer nights riding her bike to Swan Pharmacy to pick out treats at the counter!

During her undergrad years she had the opportunity to study abroad in Paris, it was during this time that Molly began contemplating a career in culinary arts. Soon after undergrad she attended culinary school in Minneapolis. Molly has worked in cafes and fine dining restaurants in the Midwest and on the West Coast. Molly returned to her Milwaukee roots in 2012 and was hired as the pastry chef for Braise Restaurant. In 2016 she took a position as Executive Pastry Chef for Black Shoe Hospitality. 

Molly began catering parties in her free time which led to the creation of Miss Molly's Pastries in 2012. The company has grown over the years to become a top wedding caterer in Southeastern Wisconsin. Molly opened Miss Molly's Cafe & Pastry Shop in 2017 just a few blocks from her childhood home. 

Cassie Hersh

Executive Chef

Cassie grew up in Germantown, WI. She spent much of her childhood at home cooking with the family. As a teenager, she worked at Culver's and took an interest in the hospitality industry. While deciding on a career path, she went to culinary camp at the Illinois Institute of Art- Chicago and knew that Culinary Arts was what she wanted to pursue. Cassie attended Waukesha County Technical College and graduated with an Associates Degree in Culinary Management in 2013. She was named WCTC's "Culinary Student of the Year" and WCTC's "Outstanding Student of the Year". While attending Culinary school, Cassie started at Bluemound Golf & Country Club in Wauwatosa as an intern. Over the course of 3 years, she worked her way from intern to Sous Chef. After two years as Sous Chef at Bluemound, Cassie joined Miss Molly's team as Executive Chef in 2017. Cassie is excited for this next season of life, and for the future of Miss Molly's.

Kira Walters

Cafe Manager

Kira grew up in Racine, Wisconsin. She received her BFA in Acting from The North Carolina School of the Arts, but she has always felt at home working in the cafe environment. After school she lived in New York City, managing a locally run and sustainably focused cafe while also exploring her acting career. She returned to the midwest in 2015 and was thrilled to discover Molly's and join the team. She continues to do local theater and works as a freelance writer on the side of managing the cafe's front of house. Thank goodness she' has a talent for juggling.

Laura Maigatter

Catering + Events Manager

Laura grew up in Milwaukee not far from Molly’s. She attended UW-Madison and worked in restaurants as a server throughout her college career. She dedicated a large portion of her 20’s to traveling the world, and even lived abroad for several years, always working in restaurants when home. Saying food was a driving force of her travels would be an understatement. After settling back in the states, she began working at Braise, where she met Molly. Always an admirer of her work ethic and sweet treats, Laura is thrilled to be able to share Molly’s work with the brides and grooms of Milwaukee. She has a passion for sustainable, locally sourced food, and a deep and abiding love of beekeeping, Not surprisingly, her favorite cake flavor at Miss Molly’s is the Wildflower Honey!