A seasonal bakery collection
for true insiders

The Crumb Club is our way of celebrating our most loyal fans, adventurous eaters, and thoughtful gift givers. Each quarter, our pastry team creates a curated collection of 3–4 brand-new, small-batch bakery items crafted exclusively for members. From cookies and bars to seasonal pastries and breads, these creations are only available to the Crumb Club. 

By joining, you’ll get an early taste of what’s next at Miss Molly’s and play a part in shaping our seasonal menu.

How it Works

Seasonal Collection

One bakery box is released each season (Winter, Spring, Summer, Fall).

pick up the last Friday of the month in January, April, July, October

Taste & Vote

Each box includes a QR code survey where members can vote for their favorite treat.

Your Voice Counts

The winning item is added to our cafe menu or seasonal rotation, and the recipe is emailed to members.

Limited Enrollment

Spots are limited each season to keep the experience special.

Membership Options

Quarterly
Membership
$65

One seasonal bakery collection (3–4 exclusive items)

A bring-a-friend pass for two complimentary pastries

Lunch on Us – one complimentary menu item of your choice

10% off Miss Molly’s retail shelf items (merchandise and packaged bakery) during your active quarter

A printed membership card to redeem your perks

Annual
Membership
$250

(Holiday Exclusive)

Four seasonal bakery collections (one each quarter, Jan–Dec)

A printed membership card with all Quarterly perks (bring-a-friend pass, Lunch on Us, 10% retail shelf discount)

A voucher for a complimentary birthday treat

Holiday Gift Bonus included in all Annual memberships

Holiday 2025 Bonus

Join before Jan 2026 and you’ll also receive a jar of Miss Molly’s jam, a package of cookies, and a gift-ready Crumb Club card

The Crumb Club

Annual Membership

Our Annual Membership includes:

  • Four seasonal bakery collections (one each quarter, Jan–Dec)

  • A membership card with all Quarterly perks (bring-a-friend pass, Lunch on Us, 10% discount)

  • A voucher for a complimentary birthday treat,

  • Exclusive Holiday Bonus: jar of Miss Molly’s housemade Strawberry jam and a bag of Sea Salt Shortbread (perfect for holiday gifting!)

Annual Membership box pick up dates include:

  • Winter - Friday, January 30th

  • Spring - Friday, April 24th

  • Summer - Friday, July 31st

  • Fall - Friday, October 30th

____________________________________

All Annual Memberships come with a holiday gift bonus. Membership materials and the holiday gift bonus can be picked up at the cafe anytime between December 16–23 during business hours.

If you do not want the holiday gift bonus or are unable to pick up, we are happy to mail the membership materials (without the gift bonus) to the billing address listed on your purchase. Please note: the price is not discounted. Please contact us directly if you would like materials mailed.

We will contact the new member by email in early January 2026 with further details about their membership.

Questions? Please contact us at hello@missmollyscafe.com or call 414-249-5665 ext. 2.

$250.00
Quarterly Membership

Our Quarterly Membership includes:

  • One seasonal bakery collection (3–4 exclusive items)

  • A bring-a-friend pass for two complimentary pastries

  • Lunch on Us – one complimentary menu item of your choice

  • 10% off Miss Molly’s retail shelf items (merchandise and packaged bakery) during your active quarter

  • A printed membership card to redeem your perks

This Quarterly Membership is for our Winter Club.

Winter Membership boxes and perks can be picked up on Friday, January 30th.

____________________________________

Shipping & Pick-Up Options
All Quarterly Memberships may be mailed or picked up in person. If you are purchasing this as a holiday gift, we strongly recommend pick-up for any orders placed after December 15 to ensure you have the materials before the holiday.

Please allow up to three days for us to prepare your membership materials for pick-up at the cafe.

We will contact the new member via email in early January 2026 with further details about their membership.

Questions? Please contact us at hello@missmollyscafe.com or call 414-249-5665 ext. 2.

$65.00

Membership with Miss Molly’s Crumb Club is perfect for a special holiday or birthday gift — or a treat for yourself!

Inquire in store or email us at hello@missmollyscafe.com for more information on how to join the club!